What Pain Sounds Like: Writing the Unsayable

A seismologist who listened to earthquakes, experimental trauma writing, and Annie Dillard's weasel: how literature finds forms for what words can't hold.

What Pain Sounds Like: How Writers Render the Unsayable

The seismologist Hugo Benioff spent decades turning the vibrations of the earth into signals he could study, and eventually into sounds he could hear. That story, told this week by JSTOR Daily, is about instruments and fault lines. It is also a surprisingly good description of what writers do. Some experiences arrive as tremors: too large, too deep, or too disordered to fit into an ordinary sentence. The work is to build a device that lets the rest of us hear them.

Read the week's literary news side by side and that problem keeps surfacing. Essays, reviews, poems, and reading lists from very different corners of the literary world are all circling the same question: what happens when the thing you need to say is exactly the thing language is worst at saying?

At Literary Hub, Ed Simon explores the limits of language to understand why "pain makes poor poets out of all of us." It is a humbling idea for anyone who loves words. We tend to assume that the most intense experiences produce the most eloquent writing. Often the reverse is true. Real suffering flattens vocabulary into a few blunt words: it hurts, it was bad, I can't explain.