The narrative unfolds in a cozy library where a family debate ensues regarding the future home of Patty Fairfield. As the discussion heats up, Patty's relatives, including her father, Uncle Charley, and Aunt Alice, engage in a lively argument over whether she should settle in Vernondale or New York City. Each side presents compelling arguments, with the New York advocates highlighting the city's social opportunities, superior schools, and cultural advantages, while the Vernondale supporters emphasize the benefits of fresh air, a close-knit community, and a healthier lifestyle. Patty, caught between the two options, is appointed as the judge of the debate. As the arguments unfold, her friends and family passionately express their views, with humor and exaggeration adding to the lively atmosphere. Uncle Charley paints a dire picture of city life, while Aunt Alice sarcastically suggests that Patty would thrive in the loneliness of a big city house. Marian, a close friend, vehemently opposes the idea of Patty leaving, declaring her determination to keep her in Vernondale. As the debate progresses, Patty grapples with her feelings about both locations, recognizing the allure of city life while also valuing her connections in Vernondale. The story captures the essence of youthful indecision and the importance of home and community.
By Carolyn Wells · First published 1920 · Genre: Young Adult, Fiction, Coming-of-Age · 24 chapters