Crooked Souls by Dashiell Hammett

A hard-boiled investigation unfolds around the abduction of a wealthy man’s only daughter. The case begins with the father urgently demanding results after receiving a ransom note demanding $50,000 in one hundred‐dollar bills, accompanied by personal items and a weak plea from his daughter. The detective is hired to gather facts from a man known for his brutal business methods and temperamental disposition. As details emerge, the father’s recollection and the testimonies of his many servants suggest that the girl, though known for her rebellious independence, had not been out of her normal routine, casting initial doubts on the nature of her disappearance. An immediate operation is set in motion: the father is instructed to have the money ready, and police detectives along with private operatives begin a careful surveillance. A choreographed money drop is arranged on a city street, and a series of shadowing maneuvers ensues. The detective observes various figures—a chunky man, a touring car, a plainclothes policeman, and later an inconspicuous woman in dark attire—whose movements hint at a trap. When the father finally attempts to deliver the ransom, he is intercepted by a mysterious figure in disguise. The encounter is chaotic, with the ransom money falling on the pavement, a brief stand-off, and the swift disappearance of the suspect, fuelled by an apparent double-cross. As the investigation continues, perturbing inconsistencies accumulate. Illustrative details include the victim’s hastily sent letter from the post office, a phone call from the girl that offers conflicting cues about her location, and a timeline that seems too rapid for a genuine kidnapping. The detective uncovers that the girl had been seen on Market Street around the time of her disappearance and that her personal effects and photographic collection reveal an unsystematic social life. A man described as Leighton, who is later identified as a known con artist, enters the investigation when evidence of a staged disguise emerges: a recently rented apartment, purchases of clothing suitable for disguising a young woman, and a suspicious drop-off address hint at collusion. Further developments include a violent confrontation in an apartment building: the detective, responding to mysterious gunshots at an uninvited door call, finds a tussle between a man and a disguised woman. The altercation provides more clues to the possibility of a contrived abduction. The dialogue between the conspirators, laced with bitter insults and recriminations, reveals a scheme in which the young woman may have orchestrated her own kidnapping to manipulate her domineering father—whose questionable business practices and authoritarian nature have long fueled domestic strife. In a final twist, the investigation points toward a carefully planned maneuver. The daughter, tired of her father's oppressive ways, appears to have collaborated with experienced swindlers who executed a deceptive operation. Their scheme involved a staged ransom exchange, a misdirected money drop, and strategic communication designed to force her father into desperate measures. As the detective pieces together the evidence—erratic telephone calls, misaligned timelines, and the conspicuous involvement of con men—the likelihood emerges that the abduction was self-induced. This conclusion is bolstered by her calculated actions, such as mailing a ransom note at an unusual hour and sending contradictory signals during her phone call. The investigation culminates in a tense reunion at a public office, where a confrontation between the father and daughter leads to an uneasy reconciliation. Faced with the threat of scandal—both due to his own dubious past and the public exposure of family strife—the father is forced to relent to her demands. Meanwhile, the apprehension of the con man involved further confirms the deceptive nature of the operation. The detective’s assessment is that the entire enterprise was a well-orchestrated fraud designed by the daughter to secure her freedom from her father’s tyrannical control.

By Dashiell Hammett · First published 2021 · Genre: Hard-boiled Detective Fiction, Crime Fiction, Mystery

More by Dashiell Hammett