The work explores the subjective nature of tobacco preferences, challenging the notion of universal standards in taste. The narrator asserts that individual preference is paramount, dismissing the idea that a collective agreement on what constitutes a "good" cigar can exist. He critiques the tendency of smokers to rely on brand reputation rather than actual flavor, suggesting that many are deceived by labels and social expectations. The narrator recounts personal experiences, highlighting the absurdity of social norms surrounding tobacco. He describes a dinner party where he substitutes expensive cigars with his own cheaper brand, revealing how perceptions of quality are often influenced by reputation rather than reality. The guests' discomfort and eagerness to leave when faced with his cigars illustrate the power of social stigma. He reflects on his own smoking habits, admitting that while he claims to have a discerning taste, he is likely influenced by branding as well. He humorously notes that he enjoys cigars that others deem undesirable, suggesting a contrarian approach to taste. The narrator expresses a preference for inexpensive cigars, particularly those from Europe, which he finds enjoyable despite their low status. The work concludes by reiterating the idea that taste in tobacco is deeply personal and subjective, shaped by individual experiences and biases rather than any objective standard. The narrator's reflections serve as a commentary on broader themes of perception, social norms, and the nature of personal preference.
By Mark Twain · First published 1901 · Genre: Essay, Humor, Non-fiction