In a mining town named Appleton, Slim Malone, a notorious bandit, becomes the focus of local ire after a series of stagecoach robberies. The town, once quiet, has transformed into a bustling hub following the discovery of gold in the nearby gorges. Malone's reputation grows as he eludes capture, leading to the formation of several posses that fail to apprehend him. The new mayor, Orval Kendricks, capitalizes on the town's frustration by promising to rid Appleton of Malone. He hires Lefty Cornwall, a famed gunfighter, to serve as deputy sheriff with a hefty salary and bonus contingent on capturing Malone. The townsfolk rally behind this decision, eager for action against the bandit. Lefty arrives in Appleton to much fanfare, but he quickly realizes the gravity of his task. As he prepares to confront Malone, he learns of the bandit's cunning and skill. Despite his bravado, Lefty feels a growing sense of doubt as he ventures into the treacherous Eagle Head Canyon, where Malone is rumored to reside. After a tense journey, Lefty discovers Malone's hideout and confronts him. In a surprising turn, Malone remains calm and unarmed, inviting Lefty to share a drink. The sheriff, despite his better judgment, succumbs to the temptation of Malone's fine whiskey. As they drink and converse, Malone's charm and wit disarm Lefty, leading to a moment of camaraderie. However, Malone seizes the opportunity to turn the tables. In a swift move, he disarms Lefty and captures him instead. The bandit ties Lefty up and sends him back to Appleton on his horse, leaving a mocking note that highlights the irony of their encounter. The townspeople awaken to find their sheriff returning in disgrace, bound and humiliated. Malone's cleverness and charisma have not only secured his freedom but also left a lasting impression on Lefty and the citizens of Appleton. The story concludes with a sense of admiration for Malone's audacity and a hint of respect for the outlaw's skill, leaving the townsfolk to ponder the nature of law and order in their rugged world.
By Max Brand · First published 1932 · Genre: Western, Adventure, Drama