A barrister seeks the help of a medical professional after a friend, Giles Herrington, is found dead in his chambers, apparently murdered. The scene is chaotic, indicating a struggle, and the medical professional discovers marks on Herrington's throat. The police inspector arrives, and they begin to gather evidence, including statements from a night porter and a laundress, who mention a mysterious visitor to Herrington's chambers shortly before his death. The investigation reveals that Herrington had a contentious relationship with a nephew, Godfrey Herrington, who had a history of financial demands from his uncle. The police focus on Godfrey as a suspect, but the evidence is circumstantial. Meanwhile, the medical professional and his colleague, Dr. Thorndyke, begin their own investigation, collecting clues from the crime scene, including a peculiar object that turns out to be an elephant's hair. As the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that the murder may be linked to a stolen ceremonial object from a West African kingdom, which Herrington possessed. The suspect, Kwaku Essien, a student and heir to the kingdom, claims he was trying to retrieve the stolen item when he encountered Herrington. A struggle ensues, leading to Herrington's death. Essien's account of the events is presented to the police, who must determine the truth behind the murder. The case raises questions about cultural heritage, theft, and the complexities of familial relationships. Ultimately, the investigation leads to a confrontation with the law, but the evidence remains inconclusive, leaving the case unresolved. The narrative explores themes of justice, morality, and the impact of personal history on tragic events.
By R. Austin Freeman · First published 1912 · Genre: Mystery, Detective Fiction, Crime