The work examines the contributions of Giotto to the art of painting, particularly in relation to his contemporaries and the evolution of artistic expression. It begins by highlighting Giotto's frescoes in Pisa, emphasizing their nobility and the potential influence between him and Dante. The text posits a question regarding whether painters drew inspiration from poets or vice versa, suggesting a reciprocal relationship in the creative arts. Giotto, a pupil of Cimabue, is noted for eclipsing his teacher, as evidenced by Dante's acknowledgment in "Purgatorio." The six significant frescoes depicting the sufferings of Job are mentioned as a testament to Giotto's mastery. The narrative asserts that while manual dexterity in the arts can improve over time, the essence of artistic expression does not necessarily evolve in a linear fashion. Instead, it suggests that the arts emerge fully formed in the early stages of a culture, akin to Minerva's birth from Jupiter. The text traces the trajectory of painting from Giotto through to Raphael, identifying a peak in artistic power during Raphael's time. However, it also notes a decline in innovation as artists began to focus on technical challenges rather than the emotive and conceptual depth of their work. This decline is illustrated through the example of sculptors creating lifeless representations, such as the tomb of Algarotti, and painters resorting to mere imitation of nature. In the contemporary context, the author observes a revival of interest in the artistic power of earlier times, though it is accompanied by skepticism regarding the actual resurgence of that power. The work ultimately reflects on the cyclical nature of artistic expression, the interplay between different art forms, and the ongoing quest for authenticity and depth in painting.
By Samuel Taylor Coleridge · First published 1906 · Genre: Art Criticism, Historical Analysis, Literary Criticism