A Reprisal by Helen Gray Cone (1887)

Name: A Reprisal
Author: Helen Gray Cone

"A Reprisal" by Helen Gray Cone is a war poem structured as a vivid dream vision in which the speaker, tormented by grief and wartime anguish, is granted by Sleep a supreme and terrible power: dominion over the air itself, like a great predatory force capable of delivering death from above. Armed with this power in the dream, the speaker soars through the night sky as a kind of avenging aerial being, crossing the sea and flying over the land of an enemy. The speaker arrives above a sheltered valley home belonging to that enemy and perceives, sleeping peacefully within, the two figures the enemy holds most dear — described as two beloved ones resting cheek to cheek, innocent and unafraid, accompanied by a personified Gray Memory. The speaker recognizes that these sleeping figures are the enemy's dearest hope and love, and that they are entirely vulnerable. The speaker also knows that people equally precious to the speaker have already been killed, presumably by the actions or forces of this same enemy. Rather than strike, however, the speaker instead calls out to the enemy, summoning him to witness the scene. The speaker's cry is one of moral confrontation rather than destruction: the speaker declares that this very act — the bombing or killing of innocent beloved ones in their sleep — is the atrocity the enemy has already committed against the speaker. The speaker then makes a pointed and anguished declaration: though it would be within the speaker's power to do the same, and though such revenge might seem justified, the speaker refuses. The refusal is framed not merely as a moral choice but as an almost instinctive revulsion — "this I would not do, yea, this I could not do." The speaker hurls this refusal at the enemy like a gauntlet, a challenge to the enemy's pride, demanding that the enemy feel the shame of the contrast between the two of them. When the enemy appears at his gate in response, the speaker observes that he looks sadder than expected. Crucially, the speaker finds that, face to face with the enemy as a human being rather than an abstraction, hatred dissolves. The speaker hates what the enemy has done but cannot hate the man himself. Before the enemy can respond, the dream ends, broken apart by the harsh reality of morning — street hawkers crying out war headlines of triumphs, defeats, horrors, and despairs, while church bells call the world to prayer. The poem operates as a meditation on the ethics of wartime retaliation, particularly in the context of aerial bombardment, which by Cone's era had introduced the deliberate targeting of civilian populations. The speaker's fantasy of reprisal is granted full imaginative reality in the dream, allowing Cone to explore what it might feel like to have that power and to choose, from an elevated moral position, not to use it. The poem does not sentimentalize the enemy or deny the speaker's grief and rage; it acknowledges both the temptation and the anguish. Instead, the refusal is presented as the thing that distinguishes the speaker from the enemy, and the speaker wants the enemy to know it — to be struck by the knowledge rather than by bombs. The concluding moment, in which the enemy's human sadness undoes the speaker's hatred, adds psychological complexity, suggesting that the true reprisal the speaker imagines is not violence but conscience: the enemy forced to confront his own acts by seeing them mirrored back through the lens of the speaker's mercy. The abrupt return to waking life, with its cacophony of war news and prayer bells, frames the dream's moral clarity against the ongoing, unresolved noise of the actual conflict.

By Helen Gray Cone · First published 1887 · Genre: War Poetry, Narrative Poetry, Romantic Poetry · 528 words

First lines

MOODS OF WAR

At the deep midnight hour / Sleep, that makes all things whole, / Indulged my tortured soul. / In the jewel-chest of dreams / He stirred the elusive gleams, / And found the gift of power, / Round, pure, and perfect power, / And laid it in my hand.

Open reader

Similar titles

Genres

War Poetry — The work explicitly addresses themes of war, conflict, and the moral dimensions of violence through the lens of a dreamer contemplating revenge against an enemy during wartime.
Narrative Poetry — The piece tells a coherent story with plot progression, character development, and resolution, following a speaker from sleep through a vengeful dream to morning awakening.
Romantic Poetry — The work employs romantic imagery and emotional intensity, with vivid descriptions of dream landscapes, celestial flight, and deeply felt moral conflicts characteristic of Romantic verse.
Allegorical Poetry — The dream sequence functions as an allegory for the moral struggle between vengeance and mercy, with symbolic elements such as the Prince of the Power of the Air and the Terror-by-Night representing abstract concepts.

What this Textopian page supports

A Reprisal is listed on Textopian as a poem by Helen Gray Cone, dated 1887 CE.

This source record anchors work identity, reading entry points, and catalog context for checking claims about the work.

Work type: Poem
Author: Helen Gray Cone
Date: 1887 CE
Language: English
Genres: War Poetry, Narrative Poetry, Romantic Poetry, Allegorical Poetry, Philosophical Poetry
Length: 528 words
Structure: 1 section, 6 paragraphs
Reading fit: Very Easy (5th Grade or below)

Good citation fit

Work identity for A Reprisal by Helen Gray Cone
Canonical title URL and first readable passage URL
Genre and topic classification from the Textopian catalog
Readability and classroom-planning context
Passage-specific claims should cite the exact /read/ URL for the relevant chapter or paragraph